Latest News
Navigating Energy Investment: Insights from Clyde & Co LLP's LatAm Arbitration Event
Navigating Energy Investment: Insights from Clyde & Co LLP's LatAm Arbitration Event
Introduction:
Clyde & Co LLP, in collaboration with Jus Mundi and Queen Mary University of London's School of International Arbitration, recently organized an insightful event focusing on the development of arbitration and investment practices in the Latin American (LatAm) region. The event brought together industry experts, corporate counsel, and institutional representatives to discuss key challenges and opportunities in the evolving landscape of energy investment in LatAm.
Obstacles and Opportunities in LatAm Investment:
The first panel, moderated by Carlos Carvalho, explored the obstacles hindering LatAm's attractiveness to investors and potential opportunities in the region. While there were positive developments, such as regulators collaborating with companies to support the energy transition, historical concerns related to complicated tax, labor, and litigation environments, coupled with regulatory uncertainty, continue to impact the region. The need for policy coordination, predictability, and innovation in LatAm was emphasized as essential for attracting investments.
Arbitrating Against State Entities:
The second panel shed light on the nuances of arbitrating against state entities in LatAm. Maria Fanou highlighted the historical opposition of LatAm countries to investor-state dispute resolution mechanisms. Nicolás Gálvez Solís discussed the challenges faced by states and their entities in arbitration, including difficulties in retaining counsel and advancing costs due to budgetary restrictions. André Tan Oh emphasized the differences in arbitrating against state-run and publicly listed entities, addressing transparency and the private nature of arbitration.
Nascent Contractual Risk-Allocation:
With a focus on mitigating risks, the discussion delved into the contractual risk-allocation strategies adopted by major players in the industry. Companies like Petróleos Mexicanos and Petrobras have updated their standard contract templates to address liability caps, exclusions, and the scope of environmental liability. The enforceability of these clauses remains to be tested, raising questions about the need for legal system adjustments. Despite challenges, the allocation of risks appears to be more negotiable in the renewable sector compared to traditional energy.
ESG and the Path to Renewables:
Environmental, Social, and Governance (ESG) considerations took center stage, with a divided perspective on fossil fuels in LatAm. The region grapples with balancing the demand for oil and gas revenue with the global push for renewables. The discussion highlighted the importance of ESG commitments, with successful initiatives demonstrating social benefits and economic advantages for investors. The path to renewables in LatAm is complex, and stakeholders must navigate this balance carefully.
Conclusion:
The event's discussions underscored the multifaceted nature of energy investment in LatAm, with Brazil emerging as a focal point. While challenges persist, such as regulatory complexities and historical concerns, there is a collective effort to enhance policy coordination, transparency, and innovation. The intersection of themes between panels highlighted the interconnectedness of investment and arbitration in the region, emphasizing the pivotal role of arbitration as a key tool in dispute resolution. As LatAm aims to transition towards cleaner energy sources, stakeholders must navigate challenges and capitalize on opportunities to foster the region's growth as a dispute and investment hub in the energy sector.
- While there were positive developments, such as regulators collaborating with companies to support the energy transition.
- With a focus on mitigating risks, the discussion delved into the contractual risk-allocation strategies adopted by major players in the industry.
- The region grapples with balancing the demand for oil and gas revenue with the global push for renewables.
